Go to main content

Media Freedom and Pluralism During Election Periods

Media Freedom and Pluralism During Election Periods

Lessons from the Atresmedia Judgment

On 8 October 2026 in the case of Atresmedia Corporación de Medios de Comunicación S.A. v. Spain (Application No. 29807/23), the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) handed down a judgement that addressed the balance between freedom of expression in the audiovisual media and the protection of political pluralism during election periods. This decision provides interesting insights into the respective responsibilities of States and media service providers in ensuring a pluralistic democratic debate.

An Election Debate at the Heart of the Case

The case originated when a Spanish television network sought to organise a televised debate bringing together the candidates from five political parties ahead of the 2019 parliamentary elections. Four of these parties were already represented in Parliament. The fifth party was an emerging party that was likely to achieve a significant electoral result, particularly given the voting intentions expressed in the polls.

Several parties already represented in Parliament who were not invited to participate in the debate challenged this decision before the Spanish electoral authority. The authority rejected the proposed format, finding that it did not ensure a sufficiently balanced representation of the various political parties. Spanish courts subsequently upheld this decision.

The television network then took the case to the ECHR, arguing that this intervention violated its freedom of expression, as guaranteed by Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

However, the Court concluded that there had been no violation of this freedom. It found that the electoral authority’s intervention pursued a legitimate aim: ensuring pluralism and equality among political competitors. The Court also took into account the fact that the decision did not constitute an absolute and general ban on debate: the media service provider remained free to organise other formats that were compatible with national requirements.

The Court recognised that States have a relatively narrow margin of discretion to regulate media coverage of election campaigns in order to ensure the neutrality of information and equality among political actors. However, this margin is not unlimited and must be exercised in a manner that respects the media’s freedom of expression.

Pluralism: A Shared Responsibility

One of the main lessons from this ruling concerns the fundamental role of the broadcast media in a democratic society. Freedom of expression not only protects the media’s right to communicate information and opinions, but also guarantees the public’s right to access them.

This right is particularly important during election periods, when citizens must be able to access diverse information that allows them to freely form their own opinions. Protecting pluralism is therefore an essential responsibility of states, which must ensure that different political viewpoints have a place in the public debate.

However, this does not mean that public authorities can make editorial decisions on behalf of the media. Media service providers remain key players  in democratic life, and their independence and editorial freedom must be safeguarded.

The Atresmedia ruling illustrates the need to strike a balance between these two requirements precisely. While States may intervene to ensure pluralism and fairness in election coverage, these interventions must be proportionate and respect the media’s freedom to decide how to inform their audience.

The 2028 Legislative Elections: ALIA Prioritises Dialogue with the Media

This decision is of particular interest to Luxembourg, in view of the upcoming 2028 legislative elections. Media coverage of election campaigns is a key concern for ALIA, whose role includes ensuring compliance with the fundamental principles of freedom of expression, media independence, and pluralism of information.

This initiative forms part of the mandates entrusted to ALIA by the 22 July 2022 law, which assigns responsibilities to ALIA regarding the organisation of media election campaigns by audiovisual media providers entrusted with a public service mission.

During the 2023 legislative elections, ALIA published guiding principles for media coverage of the election campaign, in consultation with political parties and media outlets entrusted with a public service mission. As stated in the preamble, their objective was to ensure “objective, balanced, and fair representation in the relevant media of all political movements participating in the electoral process, with a view to providing diverse, comprehensive, relevant, and critical information.”

In this context, ALIA established detailed participation criteria for official roundtables. Regarding the rest of the election coverage framework established by the relevant media outlets, the guidelines provided for ALIA to act as a mediator in the event of difficulties, without interfering in the newsrooms’ editorial decisions. This mediation helped resolve a dispute concerning the representation of the Piraten Party in Radio 100.7’s election coverage.

Ahead of the 2028 legislative elections, ALIA intends to continue this consultative process by involving the relevant media service providers and political actors in developing new guiding principles. Discussions will focus on practical arrangements for campaign coverage as well as the challenges newsrooms may face in ensuring balanced representation of the various political currents. The aim is to establish common guidelines, while respecting legal obligations and the media’s editorial freedom. ALIA is therefore at the centre of a tripartite interaction between media outlets and political parties and pays particular attention to compliance with the principles set out in the Court’s decision.

This was evident in ALIA’s decision on 24 July 2023, regarding the programme “Background am Gespréich,” broadcast on RTL Radio Lëtzebuerg on the eve of the municipal elections. ALIA determined that François Bausch’s participation in this programme, while he was a minister from the déi gréng party (more specifically Deputy Prime Minister, Minister of Defense, and Minister of Mobility and Public Works) gave  his party a level of visibility that the other political parties had not enjoyed prior to the election. RTL has appealed against this decision.

The Atresmedia ruling serves as a reminder that pluralism and media freedom must be protected in the interest of balanced democratic debate. ALIA adheres to these principles when carrying out its electoral duties. Once the new media law takes effect, it will also take on the new responsibilities entrusted to it under the European regulation on transparency and the targeting of political advertising. ALIA therefore wishes to reaffirm its position as a preferred electoral partner for both media providers and political parties, providing  assistance in determining and identifying their rights and obligations.